Recap: Becoming a Pretty Little Liar


Please be aware that there are spoilers for Pretty Little Liars in the post ahead.

My Pretty Little Liars journey began on the 15th August 2015 when I sat down to watch the Pilot and my life changed forever. Then I swiftly watched seasons one to five in a record-breaking five weeks. To say I was obsessed was an under statement.


(c) butterflycaps

The mystery surrounding Alison DiLaurentis was what drew me in to the show. She had gone missing the night of the barn sleepover and the Liars spent a year wondering exactly what had happened to their best friend. Then, at the last moment, they found her body, and us and the Liars were posed with a new question: Who Killed Alison DiLaurentis? A missing person became a murder victim, and another mystery unraveled. This was when the now infamous A messages started arriving for all four of the Liars, threatening to spill their deepest and darkest secrets, secrets that only Alison knew. So was Ali really dead? Or was she messing with the girls like she had done throughout their whole friendship?


(c) butterflycaps

The first two seasons were tightly packaged up in a neat bow. Both we well paced and the revelation that Mona was A not only reflected the books but also made sense in the way the show was constructed. But we still didn’t know anything about Alison’s death, or who had killed her. Then we got a taste of what was to come in season three, and things got a whole lot crazier. The season 2 finale parting scene depicted Mona sitting in her room at Radley, telling someone wearing a Red Coat that she had done “everything they asked her to.” Cue our minds being blown. But of course, if Mona was sitting in Radley, how come the girls were still receiving A messages?  The Red Coat character that had been introduced was a clear accomplice in the A Game and the ever-growing A team.

Original A: Mona Vanderwaal

Big A: Unknown


(c) butterflycaps

Not only was season three crazier than the two seasons before it, but it also reached the next level in terms of drama and mystery. It began with the revelation that Alison’s body had been removed from her grave and gone missing, and it looked as though the Liars were being set up by A once more. But as we’ve established A is now a Team, and the biggest shock of the show so far revealed that Toby Cavanaugh was a member. So with Toby and Mona running all over Rosewood doing A’s bidding, we saw Paige and Garrett become the next two targets on A’s hit list. What I loved about the ending of season three was that Spencer went rogue, deciding she was taking it upon her shoulders to be a double agent with the A team and get the answers her and the Liars had been looking for.

Then the Thornhill Lodge fire happened, and everything we thought we know about the show turned on its head. Both Spencer and Toby decided to be double agents to try to find out the identity of Red Coat, the master behind the A Team, but when Shana decided to set the Lodge on fire, the plan turned to disarray leaving the girls trapped inside the burning building. It seemed only divine intervention could help them, as all the girls thought they were saved by Alison… but Alison couldn’t be alive? Could she?


(c) butterflycaps

So as we came into season four, Mona and Toby were kicked off the A Team and the truth about Toby’s mother, Marion Cavanaugh, began to unravel. Did she kill herself? Or was there a more sinister end to her life? After Wilden had turned up dead, A tried to have Ashley Marin charged with his murder, and it seemed A had recruited some more minions on the path for revenge. A mysterious phone number led the girls to Ravenswood, to Mrs Grundwald who became the key to finding out about Alison’s disappearance. When the girls returned there in the annual Halloween special, they found out Ali was in fact alive, having been saved from the grave Jessica DiLaurentis had dug for her daughter by Grundwald. Ezra also was revealed to own the mysterious A-like lair in Ravenswood, and seemed as though he had been hiding his shady side all along, perhaps having deceived the girls into thinking he was an innocent (and slightly naive) teacher. Turns out he was just writing a true crime book on Alison. #disappointment


(c) butterflycaps

The girls also had an exciting revelation regarding Sara Harvey, believing she was the body in the grave. It seemed the Liars were finally on track to finding out the truth about A, until Shana turned up. Was she A? Whose side was she on? Did she want to help Ali or hurt her? Regardless, Aria managed to take care of Shana by pushing her off the stage in New York, and when the girls finally thought the A Game was over, it only got more and more threatening.


(c) butterflycaps

The next episodes after New York seemed to barrel roll in terms of drama. Ali returned to Rosewood, and soon after Mona ended up murdered at the hands of A, who tried to pin it all on Alison, as she tried to convince the jury she had been kidnapped by Cyrus the whole time she was away. All the girls ended up getting involved in the trial, and season five ended with the Liars being carted off to prison, only to be ‘saved’ by A, who took them to a different kind of prison. The Dollhouse.

The only positive aspect to being inside A’s new lair, was that the girls found out Mona was in fact alive, and masquerading as Alison to please A. The Liars thought they had it bad being stalked by A in Rosewood, now they were being tortured non-stop in a sick A game for weeks before they were found. The first half of season six revolved around the girls struggling with the after effects of the Dollhouse and finding out that the identity of A was none other than Ali’s brother, Charles DiLaurentis. Then we were promised in the episode ‘Game Over, Charles’ that the identity of Charles DiLaurentis, the A who had tortured the girls for three and a half season, would be revealed.

I. Marlene King even fashioned a pre-finale campaign, assuring us that the reveal would be fruitful, despite the same promises falling flat in the past. She assured us “It’s No Lie” which prompted fans to theories that Charles DiLaurentis was in fact Noel Kahn, wondering if Marlene was trying to tell us “It’s Noel”.


(c) butterflycaps

So as the season six mid-season finale came around, we knew we were forty minutes away from finding out who Big A was. There were so many theories circulating around the internet with incredibly well thought out ideas as to who had been behind the years of torture, but I’ll include my theory I developed down below.

A/Charles DiLaurentis: Darren Wilden


(c) butterflycaps

Wilden was the detective investigating Alison’s murder/disappearance, and I was convinced that he had faked his death with Red Coat at the end of season three. I thought Jessica DiLaurentis would have had her baby boy Charles/Darren at an early age and placed him for adoption. Then as Charles/Darren grew up, he became a Police Officer to get information/keep tabs on his mother and family. When Ali went missing, he thought the Liars might have something to do with it, and after Mona was revealed as the Original A, he teamed up with her to get information on the girls, and subsequently his half-sister Alison.

Red Coat/Black Widow: Cece Drake


Cece had been a shady character from the start, and I believed she was both Red Coat and Black Widow, as both of them appeared throughout the show wearing an Alison mask. I thought Cece would help Darren/Charles fake his own death and that she would take the blame for it, before trying to pin it on Ashley Marin. At the funeral, I thought Cece would come as Black Widow as she was currently linked to the “murder” and did not want to be seen, and wanted to make sure the fake funeral went off without a hitch.

Obviously, the result was much, much different, as we saw Cece Drake revealed to be Big A, also known as Charlotte who had transitioned when she was sixteen. What I wanted from the mid-season finale was to be totally and utterly shocked, to the same extend I was when Toby was revealed to be on the A Team and when Ezra was shown to be the owner of the mysterious lair in Ravenswood. Instead, I already felt like I knew Cece was involved in the mystery somehow, and the fact that she was revealed to be A wasn’t surprising at all.

I felt very indifferent to her story that she told Alison in Radley. I felt sorry for her that she had grown up inside a mental institution and somewhat proud that she had decided to come out and be her true self, but that was where my feelings finished. I couldn’t get past the plot holes, the bad editing and filming, and the parts of the story that didn’t make sense. I was left wanting more, and as the next episode flashed forward to five years later, I still felt the longing for answers and closure that the mid-season finale hadn’t provided for me.


Original A: Mona Vanderwaal

Big A: Cece Drake

Uber A/Big Bad: Unknown

Regardless, we were promised more answers, and as we saw the girls reunite after college, with a new Big Bad Uber A on the loose. Could the A game work for a third time after the disastrous Big A reveal? Then came the rumours of a #TwinonPLL that roared like rapid fire all over the internet. Suddenly, we were fueled with theories again. Who could possible have a twin? What did this mean for the rest of the series? Was the twin the new Big Bad Uber A? Cue us re-watching every past episode for twin clues.

So here was my original theory on the season six finale and the #TwinonPLL.

The Liars believed Sara Harvey was the one antagonising them but I thought in the finale she was going to turn up dead at the hand of Big Bad/Uber A. This would reveal to the Liars that someone else was going after them, not Sara. I believed Sara Harvey was antagonising the Liars with the Amoji threats, but she was trying to avenge the death of Charlotte, believing (initially) that one of the Liars/all of the Liars killed Charlotte out of revenge of her being A.

I believed Big Bad killed Sara as, after much digging, Sara almost uncovered the truth that Big Bad killed Charlotte. I predicted that Big Bad was Melissa Hastings, who killed Charlotte out of revenge/paranoia for knowing/revealing that Melissa buried Bethany Young alive.

In regards to the #TwinonPLL, I believed Sara and Bethany were twins, similar to the Sara Shepard’s book plot, and at some point, they switched places. This meant that “Bethany Young” who was a resident in Radley, was actually Sara Harvey, and the “Sara Harvey” we knew (and hated) was truly the ‘explosive’ Bethany who grew up with Charlotte in Radley. This gave her a further motive being The Avenger.

So ‘Bethany Young’ (who was actually Sara Harvey) tried to escape from Radley “that night” and used Charlotte’s clothing as she knew she had out privileges, but was hit over the head by Mona and buried alive by Melissa. So Sara Harvey (the real Sara Harvey) was the body buried in Alison’s grave, not Bethany Young, which tied in nicely to why there was a missing person’s campaign for Sara Harvey around the time Ali went missing.

(Side note: I think image we saw of Melissa talking to Cece wearing the yellow dress was actually Melissa talking to Ali AFTER she buried Bethany Young believing her to be Ali. She was probably quizzing her on how she got out of the grave!)

Which brings me back to Melissa. Charlotte and the Liars both knew that Melissa killed Bethany. Melissa being Big Bad ties in nicely with the Hastings Campaign.

  • Twins: Sara/Bethany.
  • Avenger: Sara Harvey.
  • Big Bad: Melissa Hastings.


(c) butterflycaps

Obviously, the reveal went nothing like I’d planned. The late Jessica DiLaurentis was found to have had a twin sister named Mary Drake, who had a little boy named Charles whilst locked in Radley. Jessica and Kenneth had adopted the baby and raised him as their own. This meant that Cece and Jason weren’t brother and sister but first cousins, and that Ezra’s conclusion that Jessica DiLaurentis was A was half right as he could have been talking about Mary. Elliot Rollins was also revealed to be in on the act, marrying Alison to con her out of the inheritance left by Charlotte/Cece, who Rollis had been in love with before she died. This confirmed Elliot and Mary were the Avengers of Charlotte’s death. Did it also mean they were working together as Big Bad/Uber A Team, or is that title reserved for Charlotte’s killer? Who is AD who texted the group in the last moments of the episode? Has Alison DiLaurentis been behind it the whole time? Or is AD another Drake sibling we need to look out for? I guess we’ll have to wait until season seven.


(c) butterflycaps

So what can we expect with the final season of Pretty Little Liars that starts this coming June? Well, here are a few questions I know that I want answered:

What did Ali do all the time she was away from Rosewood?

How much contact with Charlotte did Ali have whilst she was away? How much did Ali know about Cece and the A Game? For example, why were Ali and Cece both wearing Red Coats?

Why did Cece frame Ali for Mona’s (fake) death? If Cece wanted an Alison for her Dollhouse, she could have manipulated her friendship with Ali and kidnapped her?

What were Cece’s connections with Wren?

Who killed Jessica DiLaurentis?

How much does Mona know and who’s side is she really on?

How did Sara Harvey end up running with Cece?

Why did Lesli have so many fake glasses?

So considering that season seven is going “to be the end of the show as we know it”, what do I want to happen in the end?

Here’s what we know: Mary Drake and Elliot Rollins are avenging the death of Charlotte, as Mary is her biological mother and Elliot was her lover. They wanted the Carissimi Group Inheritance to go to the rightful heirs – themselves. Now that Alison has married Elliot and checked herself into rehab, he has full control of her assets.

I believe/hope that in the end Alison is playing all of them. I think underneath this “Changed Alison” is really the manipulative girl she used to be, and still is. Alternatively, I think my theory on Melissa Hastings still stands, that she is afraid of Charlotte who knew she buried Bethany Young alive, and killed Charlotte to keep her quiet. I believe Melissa killed Charlotte and staged her suicide, informed how by the article that Spencer wrote.

Let me know in the comments what questions you want answered in the seventh, and final season of Pretty Little Liars, and what you think of the show so far?


(c) butterflycaps